Speaker Cable Thickness Does Not Matter


Go to any store, ask any bunch of posters in a forum, read any hifi article off the web and they’ll tell you that the thicker the speaker cable, the better, because it has “lower resistance”.

In the 60s and 70s, when hifi cables were commonly made of wire too thin to be considered speaker cable, there was certainly some truth to this.

These days, even the bare minimum cable is thicker than 20 AWG, and believe it or not, speaker cable thickness makes almost NO difference to sound quantity, and absolutely ZERO difference to sound quality.

Why?

1. Wattage does not matter

Let’s take a 20AWG cable, a microbe in speaker cable terms these days. A typical copper 20AWG cable has a resistance of approx 1 ohm per 100 foot length (a fairly long standard use length in domestic hifi).

Resistance per 1000 feet

Typical resistance per 1000 feet

A 1 ohm resistance in an 8 ohm system drops power by 11%. A 1 ohm resistance in a 4 ohm system drops power by 20%.

Sounds like heaps? Well, considering that this is possibly the worst case senario, no. A 100 foot long run through 20AWG cable, using 4 ohm speakers, will give you just 20% power loss.  What’s 20% power loss in real terms? Well, of course, you already know that wattage does not matter, right? And how little a % change in power affects sound levels? Even halving the power reduces the sound level by a mere 3dB, or 3% on typical 1 to 100 log-scaled volumn controllers.

And we’re really talking worst case scenario. If you’re using 17 AWG cable into a 15 foot run driving 8 ohm speakers (more typical application), you’ll end up with so little loss that it’s not even worth the decimal places.

2. Resistance causes zero loss in sound quality

This is far more important than the first point. Power and power delivery is easy to control. You can always turn up the volumn, buy a more powerful amplifier, buy more sensitive speakers. But what’s the important factor that “beginner” enthusiasts miss?

The fact that sound quality is not affected by resistance.

This is the reason a 100W amplifier could cost $200 and another $200,000. Why are high end amplifiers not all 1000W? They’re made for accuracy, not power.

Similarly, a good speaker cable has qualities which colour the sound much less than a poor one.

Everyone who’s taken high school science knows a little about resistance. V=IR, P=IV, etc. What you don’t realise is that in the real world, there is a whole other dimension of force that affects sound quality more dramatically than anything else. It’s called “reactance”.

Reactance and the behavior of reactance is the real dark force in what determines a quality speaker cable. A cable with low resistance can have high reactance, and as a result, not only be detrimental to sound, but add to the impedance of the wire. What’s impedance? We’ll get to that later. Only reactance colours the sound, and reactance only happens in high frequency (higher than the zero hz used to measure resistance). Resistance only has an effect on power. It simply makes everything a smaller version of itself. Reactance, on the other hand, can convert certain frequencies into others. Reactance introduces more frequencies, ones that were never in the original signal. Reactance behaviour is also relatively unpredictable when taking into account the internal behaviors of connected equipment.

3. Impedance is much more important than resistance

If you notice carefully, point 1 had calculations that never even considered reactance (much like the rest of the world).  But reactance has an equal affect as resistance does on power delivery. A speaker cable with near zero resistance could, in theory, be substantially detrimental to power output due to reactance.

Impedance is the combined reactance and resistance of the cable. Impedance is the “real” resistance when an AC signal is passed through the cable, and because measurements for speaker cables are only ever done in DC, you never know what the impedance might be.

A speaker cable with tiny resistance can, if designed improperly or used incorrectly, be more detrimental to both power AND sound quality than one of much higher resistance. And don’t think that any cables are immune to this. I’ve seen even “high end” cables being passed as quality cables when they’ve clearly not been made with impedance reduction in mind.

Conclusion

I admit, the industry is full of people selling ghosts as gold and chalk for cheese. But don’t think that there’s no truth to “quality speaker cable”. A speaker cable isn’t better simply because it’s fatter. There are thousands of reasons why certain designs can, and do, make a better cable. And this is just the tip of the iceberg in the weird and real world of analogue electronics.

  • Share/Bookmark
  1. No comments yet.
(will not be published)

  1. online casinos